Download E-books A Commentary on Homer's Odyssey, Volume 1: Introduction and Books I-VIII PDF

By Alfred Heubeck, Stephanie West, J. B. Hainsworth

This 1st publication of a statement compiled by means of a world group of students comprises an advent discussing past learn at the Odyssey, its relation to the Iliad, the epic dialect, and the transmission of the textual content.

Show description

Read or Download A Commentary on Homer's Odyssey, Volume 1: Introduction and Books I-VIII PDF

Best Ancient Greece books

The Oresteia: Agamemnon; The Libation Bearers; The Eumenides

Within the Oresteia Aeschylus addressed the bloody chain of homicide and revenge in the royal family members of Argos. As they circulate from darkness to gentle, from rage to self-governance, from primitive ritual to civilized establishment, their spirit of fight and regeneration turns into an enduring tune of get together.

The Poetry of Sappho

This present day, millions of years after her start, in lands distant from her local island of Lesbos and in languages that didn't exist whilst she wrote her poetry in Aeolic Greek, Sappho continues to be a huge identify between fans of poetry and poets alike,. Celebrated all through antiquity because the ultimate Greek poet of affection and of the non-public lyric, famous specifically for her limpid fusion of formal poise, lucid perception, and incandescent ardour, this day her poetry can also be prized for its uniquely bright participation in a residing paganism.

The Economies of Hellenistic Societies, Third to First Centuries BC

This option of essays through key names within the box of historical economies within the 'Hellenistic' age (c. 330-30BCE), presents crucial interpreting for a person attracted to the evolutionary development blocks of monetary historical past within the japanese Mediterranean and neighbouring areas. Case reviews examine administration and associations; human mobility and usual assets; the function of other brokers - temples and towns, in addition to rulers - in improving assets and circulating wealth; the levers exerted by means of monopolies and by means of disparate prestige teams, together with slaves.

Ancient Greek Women in Film (Classical Presences)

This quantity examines cinematic representations of historic Greek girls from the geographical regions of delusion and heritage. It discusses how those lady figures are resurrected at the monstrous reveal by way of diversified filmmakers in the course of various historic moments, and are accordingly embedded inside of a story which serves a variety of reasons, looking on the director of the movie, its screenwriters, the studio, the rustic of its beginning, and the sociopolitical context on the time of its creation.

Additional resources for A Commentary on Homer's Odyssey, Volume 1: Introduction and Books I-VIII

Show sample text content

I 99-101, 356-9, with nn. ). T h e marginal obelos alerted the person to a doubt approximately authenticity. M odern discussions o f Zenodotus’ paintings have focused at the query o f no matter if, and, if that is so, to what quantity, he brought his personal conjectures. a few o f his readings appear to us blatant conjectures, however it can't be proven that they originated with him. said usually phrases the query m ay look of mild significance: we will not often 26 Or, if he wrote one, it used to be misplaced by the point of Aristarchus; yet this turns out not likely. forty two T H E T R A N S M I S S I O N OF T H E T E X T e th a t an a n cie n t e d ito r w as n e v e r e n titled to in c lu d e his o w n em en dation s in his ed itio n s, th o u g h u n d o u b te d ly th e p o ssib ility m akes it h a rd e r fo r us to g a in a c le a r v ie w o f th e tran sm issio n . W e shall d o b e tte r to co n sid e r a p a r tic u l. a. r case. A c c o rd in g to the sch o lia o n Od. iii three thirteen C r e te , n o t S p a r ta , w as m entioned because the time period in u s o f T e le m a c h u s ’ jo u r n e y in Z e n o d o tu s ’ tex t ninety three at i , 285: OVTOS O TOTTOS dv€TT€iae Z-qVObOTOV ev TOLS TT€pi TTjS inoSrifilas TrjAepdxov SioAov ry v Kprjrrjv evavrt rijs Znaprrfs ttoulvoU toli yap tovtwv tujv Aoyojv Kara to aiunrwpfvov dtcqKoivai tov Neoropa rrapd tov TrjAefiaxov o ti Kai aA A a^ ocre n fp l tov iraTpos irevoofievos TraptaxfuaaTo vAeiv, Sio Kai iv rrj a ' paifjioSia eypai/re “ irepAjtuj eight’ i s KprjTTjv re Kai is IJvAov rjpiadoevTa” (i ninety three) Kai rj Adr/vd aAAaxov (2 eight four -6 ) “ irpwra pev is FlvAov iA d i, KtWev S’ is KprjTTjv T€ [Se KprjTTjvSe B u ttm a n n ] n a p ’ ISopevrja avaKTa• \ os yap SevTaros fjAdev ^ a tc u v x a^KOXlTU')V(jOV-” D e sp ite the d o g m a tic to n e o f this n o te , w h a t is claimed a b o u t Z e n o d o tu s ’ re a so n in g ca n b e no m o re th a n a wager, and the ab se n ce o f co rre s p o n d in g C r e ta n v a r ia n ts w h e re S p a r ta is m entioned as T e le m a c h u s ’ d e stin a tio n in ii (2 14 , 32 7, three five nine ) 27 im p lies that Z e n o d o tu s w as n o t s y ste m a tic a lly a lte rin g the te x t in a c c o rd a n c e w ith som e p riv a te th e o ry . T h e se re a d in g s are g e n e r a lly dism issed as a r b itr a r y a n d e cce n tric conjectures; y e t th e y a re so g l. a. r in g ly in co n sisten t w ith th e su b seq u en t n arra tiv e th a t th e y m ig h t b e th o u g h t to d eserv e severe c o n sid e ra tio n as lectiones difficiliores. I f Z e n o d o tu s , h a v in g fo u n d those re a d in g s in a m an u scrip t to w h ich (r ig h tly o r w ro n g ly ) he a tta c h e d im p o rta n c e , ju d g ed th e m too o d d to b e co n je ctu re s, w e sh o u ld re sp e ct his reasoning. it truly is te m p tin g to sp e c u l. a. te th a t w e m ig h t h a v e h e re an a u th en tic re lic o f a n e a r lie r d e sig n fo r the T e le m a c h y ; c e rta in ly O d ysseu s’ co ver-sto ries re v e a l a prepared in terest in C r e t e ,28 a n d it w o u ld no longer be s u rp risin g i f the p o e t h a d co n te m p l. a. te d ta ok in g T e le m a c h u s to go to identity o m en ecu s b u t c h a n g e d his m in d befo re he w as fa r a d v a n c e d .

Rated 4.48 of 5 – based on 18 votes